Posted 04 June 2010 - 03:05 AM
Nelson and Don, thanks for the replies.
Don, this was not a kit. The body is a basswood Yamaha Pacifica Stratocaster style, dating back to the mid-90's. It was a real pain to remove the original finish and sand down to get rid of a few major scratches. It had been in the hands of a few others, and had a few unusual routed out areas to the say the least. The neck is a new one, rosewood fret board over maple, which I think is pretty standard. I got this via eBay, as I did the body. Being a Yamaha and not a Fender meant that there was a lot of work required to resurrect the body into a playable guitar. A common and standard Fender fretboard did not fit, so there was a lot of shaping to get it to fit the Yamaha body. The neck wasn't a perfect fit either, but I was lucky in that a standard neck was a tad large, so it was easier to remove material than add material to make a tight joint.
The electronics were new, which I inserted myself, but since I'm not a player, I had no idea what was a good set-up and what was a great set-up. Also, since this was a Yamaha, the most common of electronics did not fit into the body without additional routing and clearance work. In the end I opted for rather inexpensive, generic components. My goal was to make a functional piece of art, and if someone wanted to take it off the wall and jam out for the weekend they could. If they wanted to make this a regular jiggin' guitar for a world tour or local house band, then they would have to replace the electronics to bring it up to that level of play.
If I had to do it all over again, I think the Saga kits is what I would consider next. From what I have heard, the fit and finish is good, and the electronics are fair. With a kit you don't have to worry about removing an existing finish, or finding a surprise under that finish when it's gone (like repairs or lamination). The Saga kits are made to fit together and sound good without a lot of hassle. Of course I don't listen to myself, and have a new Fender Affinity Telecaster waiting in the wings for when I am ready to tackle that, maybe a Fall project due to the humidity here in Florida.
Art without engineering is dreaming; Engineering without art is calculating.